I have so much to write about and I'm not really sure where to start (or to finish) , so I hope you will bear with me if I start to ramble. I believe I speak for all of the individuals like myself who are involved in dog rescue when I talk about the frustration and the heartbreak that is part of everyday life, and that can boil over into anger too when things become overwhelming. Every morning when I check my emails I know there will be a few from people wanting to surrender their dogs, and today was no exception. If it's a young poodle (see the photo below), then at least I know it will find a new home very quickly, but even the young mongrels will probably spend their rest of their days waiting.
The excuses for giving up dogs vary, with some - really very few - perfectly reasonable and understandable, but most are entirely due to the human owners. Whether it's behaviour (the poodle isn't toilet trained at 2 years of age), having a baby, moving home, these are nothing to do with the dogs themselves.
I was given a very good example of this when I was finally able to take the two dogs, now re-named as Joe and Merlin, out of AFCD kennels (Pokfulam) after they had been incarcerated there following the sudden death of their owner, a single woman. These dogs had been taken in by HKDR as very young puppies, and had been together since birth so they were very bonded. One was more confident and was the "caretaker" of the other, so what did the Veterinary Officer at AFCD do? She separated them, despite my plea that they be kept together.
By the time we were able to take the two out they were absolutely terrified, and it took a long time to be able to gently coax them. The only good part of this experience was seeing them greet each other, and once we were in the car (driven by the person who had been acting as liaison between the police and myself, and who was the only one permitted to act on behalf of the deceased), both dogs calmed immediately. By the time we got to the Tai Po Homing Centre, they were like two different personalities.
If you didn't know, there are four AFCD Animal Management Centres, each with a Veterinary Officer (VO) who is in charge. So there is a difference between how each Centre is managed, how the animals are treated and assessed. AFCD staff themselves are government employees who don't actually choose to work with animals, they are simply assigned. Over the years I have met the best and the worst of them, and I'm always grateful to those who show kindness and empathy towards the dogs, all of whom are there thanks circumstance, not choice.
In the case of Joe and Merlin, the police were also involved, and they were very helpful. In fact they were there to oversee the freeing of the dogs, and I found out that one of the officers was himself an adopter of two HKDR dogs. So thanks where it's due. Joe and Merlin was very scared of the AFCD staff, who were unable to remove Joe from his kennel. so I think you will understand what I'm trying to say. If the VO had been asked to assess these dogs for re-homing she would not have considered them suitable, yet as soon as they were in the car and together they were very sweet.
There are many other dogs at AFCD in the same situation and who will never be lucky enough to be released. I refuse to use the word "euthanasia" except when it fits the situation, as it means a merciful death, done when it's the kindest and most humane option. These dogs aren't euthanised, they're killed.
The point of this story is to demonstrate very clearly how dogs react and respond to their situations, and to the humans who are responsible for them. Whenever we're told that the dogs are difficult or untrainable, aggressive and so on, there is always a reason. There are only very rare cases where a dog is aggressive by nature due to some brain malfunction, and the rest is down to treatment and training.
Almost all of the dogs that have come to live with me on Lamma have been those that were difficult, probably impossible, to home, yet they have all become "good" dogs over time. I know that most would never have made suitable family pets, but at the same time they can live quite happily in a home with other dogs and people and not be a problem.
Now, who can offer a home to Joe and Merlin, as a pair of course.